Dies Snarkae [undated]
May. 2nd, 2005 11:41 amHello, Sythyry! I am an offworlder, and I have recently finished reading the entirety of your journal, and many of the replies therein. I would like to write some messages to you that may not be relevant to the most recent entry in your journal, but may be interesting for you to hear. As near as I can tell, most of the people who have replied to your journal seem to have come from my world. As such, you are probably one of the few Primes -- or even sentients -- with a reliable connection to otherworld information.
[Bard notes: "Remember that Sythyry is naive, prejudiced against nonprimes (and various kinds of primes), more inclined to produce snarky comments than think carefully about things, rather defensive when zie feels zie is being attacked, touchy about things that make sense in zir culture even when they do not in ours, and not a vehicle for zir author's opinions." Zie is being somewhat less accurate than usual in this note. Well ... actually zie got the impression that you were scorning zir whole world, so zie got downright pissy by the end. Zie's new to the internet, after all. Sorry about that! -bb]
Well, I hardly know what to say to a monster who has read my entire life's story before even being introduced! Um ... perhaps... It is a pleasure to make your acquaintance as well? Please, in the interest of fairness, would you be so kind as to tell me your entire life's story?
Have you ever thought how much this might benefit you? Do you know anyone, other than the gods of your world, who has a reliable means of communication with otherworlders?
I imagine that Glikkonen does, since zie built my means for doing so. I'm not sure about anyone else in particular, but it would hardly surprise if Esory had some sort of peculiar device for it in her basement built by her five-times-great grandmother; her whole family tradition involves Locador, after all. I'm not quite sure how to bring up the subject.
For people I don't actually know -- well, surely most of the greater elementals and angels would, since they're mostly from outside my world, I think. I imagine that any of the various Locador wizards who bodily trotted off to other worlds could arrange some reliable form of chatting -- a messenger service if nothing else.
That's all I can think of at the moment.
And, as an aside, I am uncertain about this matter of reliability. I cannot see you -- I cannot sense you -- I cannot tell, save by your words, what sort of an entity you might be. Perhaps, somewhere in the murky worlds outside of the World Tree, there could be an entity capable of imperfect honesty, or one who might find it amusing to play tricks on an inexperienced Zi Ri. I can find such entities in my own social set, after all -- why not outside of my world as well?
Consider the people who wrote the Water Tree stories. They show how popular fiction about other, outlandish worlds is to Primes... now, imagine if you were to take up writing, creating stories of things of universal interest to Primes (stories of love, loss, death, birth, and the interactions amongst people and other people, as well as the world around them) set in a world not unlike the one we represent.
I have considered them -- I have considered them to be scoundrels, to be poor at thinking through the consequences of their choices, to be flimsy liars and insipid writers. I think that joining their ranks would take me thirty thousand years to live down!
Besides, I have no desire to write whatsoever. I'm sure I should be quite dreadful at it.
[Bard wonders why, if this is true, Sythyry has (1) written about two hundred thousand words + html tags in under a year, and (2) made a magic pen as zir most recent Enchantment exercise. -bb]
Imagine if you could combine that with some of our knowledge on aspects of commerce that seem to have not been developed on your world -- knowledge of distribution, of marketing, of efficient ways to set up an organization, ways of making and investing money. Now, think of how much money you could make doing this!
Hmph. You have read my entire life's story -- do I seem so very concerned with making money? I should hope not! I do hope not! If I am concerned with some matter of personal gain, I do hope that I have managed to convey my true intent on the topic, which is to become sufficiently good at Enchantment that I can command respectable prices for my works and not have to think about money again. In particular, to be able to construct devices of substantial value and skill and power, and thereby be an valued and respectable gentleman-wizard.
And as an immortal, think of the possible social and political changes you could make by introducing the possibility of different types of societies to your culture. From what I have read of your journal and of other resources I have found on the nature of your world, it seems that many ideas that could improve the standard of living of primes on the World Tree that have been developed here have not been developed in your world yet.
Well, I can hardly debate with you on the topic of ideas which nobody in my world has though of. What might be an example of such a thing?
In any case, I am only interested in making one particular change: that one being, well, the greater social allowances made for transaffectionate Orren and Zi Ri.
You have enough time to learn about us, to come up with well-reasoned opinions on aspects of our culture, and decide for yourself whether this or that particular cultural or governmental concept would be beneficial to release on the World Tree.
I'm afraid that my translation may be imperfect, and may, perhaps, introduce subtexts and shades of meaning which are not strictly intended. Do I read this properly as saying, "The cultures and governments of the World Tree are vile and vulgar, and should be tossed aside in favor of the wholly superior ones available on my home world?"
For example, you have probably noticed that many of us have rather strange opinions on nobility and on treating many who your culture considers inferior as equals. We have these opinions because one of the particular nations on our world, the "American" nation, holds these ideals... and these ideals, amongst others, has led us to be the most powerful nation currently on our world, and thus the one whose citizens are most likely to have the advanced tools to interact with your world in this sort of journal.
My non-girlfriend who changes her name frequently has similar opinions -- as does my roommate Agrimony, in principle, though he seems rather feeble about them in practice.
One of the things we have learned is that, especially when transportation, cultural crossover, and trade from area to area is relatively fast, reliable, and cheap, that certain systems of government and commerce become more effective than others. One such example is that hereditary nobility, as well as the structured layers of power that come with the existance of a noble class, is relatively inefficient. Now, the World Tree might not have fast means of travel or communications or commerce from area to area, but as these systems develop, --and they will, and you'll probably be there to see it-- your world will probably come to see that small, fractured city-states bickering amongst each other with noble families ruling them isn't the best way to do things. Now imagine if you could influence some of the changes that might change the face of your world? How do you feel about that?
I feel that reviving the Calanchian Empire would not be a good idea. For one thing, Yylhauntra would surely scold me for it. Since zie did not scold me much about loving an Orren, I feel that I am living on borrowed unscoldedness here.
On the topic of small bickering city-states, and somewhat on the topic of nobility in general: you must remember that the World Tree is a fairly dangerous place for us. The Verticals are wild, even in ancient Vheshrame -- we have a whole nendrai and a partial chromodon living down there, for gods' sake! -- and we must be sure to be able to defend ourselves.
(Clearing them out is not a viable option, even if it could be done. The gods would simply make more monsters, worse ones. Annoying gods!)
Now, the system of small bickering city-states is a crucial one to this. When our states contend against each other, our heroes become skillful and mighth and numerous. Now, these are the very heroes we rely on to protect us from the Verticals-beasts and whatever other insidious things the gods come up with.
And if we tried to centralize more? Some cities would be stripped of their heroes, and left for the monsters to eat. It is important that each city have its own power. Even the Duke of Vheshrame, who craves power more than most, is building a league rather than a kingdom.
Or, for something more harmless, what of all the culinary arts that knowledge from another world could bring! You could start your own restaurant making items completely unique to your world! You could start major trends! You could get foods named after you! Wouldn't that be fun? Or, since we have literature that gives at least a basic idea on what the current ability of magic is in your world, you might want to ask us for new and creative (but not necessarily complex or difficult) ideas on how to use magic!
I am unsure about the prospects of importing proper ingredients. For one instance, I understand that the dried chilis in your world are seedpods, not flowers. I can't imagine that they would taste the same -- to my primary clientele, which is, of course, Cani.
And the concept of having a food named after me ... children all over the world asking for a "Sythyry Pizza" seems rather, well, cannibalistic.
Or, if you don't want to change anything just yet, knowing about it can't hurt! Knowing about a world that doesn't have (visible) bickering gods, and whose reality is not governed by fickle elementals, but by natural laws that can be uncovered by forms of natural science mostly unknown on your world can't be detrimental to learn! It also seems that, based on some of the past history of the replies to this journal, you have at least rudimentary access to our largest compilation of knowledge and lore on our world -- the Internet. Think about what that might mean to you, should you decide to use it!
Well, it might be detrimental if I spend too much time on it and thereby neglect studies of more personal relevance. I am not sure what point studying such an unrealistic sort of place might have to me.
Iska, now... I imagine that mathematics is the same anywhere, and she might learn something of value to her. She's welcome to it, too, if it encourages her to move away from Vheshrame.
If there's anything else in common between our two worlds that can be discovered simply in words, I don't know it. For example -- what use to me is it to read the great classics of your world's literature? When I quote from them to my friends, I shall be given a gift of blank stares and nervous tittering suggesting that I am insane.
Why don't you ask us to elaborate on these topics, or about this world? It will be fascinating, at least!
Well ... I shall do it! Please elaborate upon these topics, your world, or other things upon which you wish to elaborate!
no subject
Date: 2005-05-02 03:51 pm (UTC)I am only startled that zie did not suggest, instead, that you send a chef or two to teach us Vheshrame cooking styles. My city is always open to new and interesting ways of cooking, either new foods (mostly vegetables that had not been grown in our area) or new ways of preparing them. The logistics of the former seem impossible: you can send us your words, and read ours in return, but that doesn't allow for the transport of people or even plant seeds.
The mathematicians on our world also believe that mathematics is the same everywhere; it may be that they, as much as Iska, could benefit from communicating with her.
no subject
Date: 2005-05-02 04:17 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-05-02 04:42 pm (UTC)(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2005-05-02 04:02 pm (UTC)Your communications and disribution networks COULD certainly be made faster by a few orders of magnitude. Oh, if only our world had the access to magic that yours does. Hrm. Well, maybe that wouldn't be such a good thing (thinks about Locador delivered fusion bombs). We do die a bit more easily than you do. My own employment is in the communications industry on my world at the moment.
A dedicated Rassimel could probably create a package and mail parcel business utilizing gates and skyboats, purely as an exercise in could-it-be-done. But I doubt it would be necessary as your fractured political and economic system makes long distance travel and communication less of a priority on your world.
I wish that I could come for a visit. But I doubt it would be particularly healthy for me; besides my lack of the type of mind/body/spirit connection that you do and an utter and complete lack of magic, I would be considered a monster and be unable to go to any of the intersting places, and the gods themselves might show up to kick me out of the universe... and "Here" might not particularly care about how and where I wound up when given the boot. :/
Loxley
no subject
Date: 2005-05-02 04:15 pm (UTC)Loxley
no subject
Date: 2005-05-02 04:18 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-05-02 04:09 pm (UTC)How about a Sloppy Sythyry? *grins, ducks and runs*
no subject
Date: 2005-05-02 05:11 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-05-02 04:31 pm (UTC)I was not kidding, a while back, when I said that we could destroy your world. We stand at the brink of destroying our own.
no subject
Date: 2005-05-02 04:39 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-05-02 04:46 pm (UTC)(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:I heartily disagree!
From:Re: I heartily disagree!
From:(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2005-05-02 04:55 pm (UTC)Allow me to apologize...
Date: 2005-05-02 05:39 pm (UTC)My tone was rude and impulsive and much more condescending than I meant! I didn't consciously mean to say that your world was worse than ours, or to insult you or your world. However, rereading my comments, it seems that, for not trying to, I really managed to act like a stuck-up snob. I'm sorry.. I'm sure there is plenty of things we can learn from you and your world! I just... well, I get overexcited sometimes. And I'm very proud of my culture and my nation sometimes, maybe even more than is really deserved. And, also, I'm not very diplomatic when I get enthusiastic about something!
Given that... could you at least reread what I wrote, and think of it as if it came from someone who means well, but doesn't really know how to express it? Maybe rethink some of your comments, while I rethink some of mine?
Thank you,
Gavin
Re: Allow me to apologize...
Date: 2005-05-02 06:30 pm (UTC)As a first-year Academy student, I of course know nobody -- nobody -- at all like this.
I'm not very diplomatic when I get enthusiastic about something!
And as a devoted admirer of Orren I of course know nobody -- nobody -- at all like this, either.
So of course I accept your apology.
Which bits would you like to revisit?
no subject
Date: 2005-05-02 06:00 pm (UTC)No... I more meant that, "There are other systems of government and aspects of culture that have different strengths and weaknesses than the ones that exist on your world, which may be worth studying and may be worth writing about and possibly publishing in such a way so that the idea of them at least exists on your world."
no subject
Date: 2005-05-02 06:31 pm (UTC)About government...
Date: 2005-05-02 06:58 pm (UTC)In our culture, feudalism started to decline when society stopped being such an agrarian society, and became more and more money based, with more liquid assets, rather than a heredity title or ownership of land providing the basis of power.
Is this similar to certain patterns in your society?
Re: About government...
From:Re: About government...
From:Re: About government...
From:Re: About government...
From:Re: About government...
From:Re: About government...
From:Re: About government...
From:Re: About government...
From:Re: About government...
From:Re: About government...
From:Re: About government...
From:no subject
Date: 2005-05-02 07:22 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-05-02 07:23 pm (UTC)I mean, I'm sorry to hear that.
(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:Defeated color shades in monster culture
Date: 2005-05-02 08:21 pm (UTC)Nowadays, there are two more common political factions in the empire which thus developed. Both are idealistic in their own way, but have different theories on how exactly a perfect world should be created.
One, among other stances on a variety of issues, is apathetic to the culture of the defeated shade and feels that they should probably be best off to just mix into the new civilization and be granted only that aid needed to help their children become effective members of their society, assuming it will all come out in the mix once the invaded shade has joined them fully. Any distress or problems that this process might cause is not generally contemplated, and any difference between cultures is handwaved away with irritation.
The other, among their many other positions on a variety of other issues, is horrified by the callousness and inhumanity of the first in ignoring the great and superior traditions of the defeated shade. Many of them in my experience would prefer instead that they be placed in historical re-enactment ghettoes, devoid of the superior devicery from the invaders that makes their lives safer and easier. There, they would be allowed to live impoverished lives, re-enacting the mostly lost traditions from before the invasion, for the edification and peace of mind of the "inferior" victor culture. Interestingly enough, this does not prevent the people of this faction from becoming outraged and wanting the right to veto or change the pieces of my ancestors' culture which they find personally abhorrent.
I will admit that it is a troubling problem, and I don't see any truely satisfying answer; I, along with my close family, tend to the first, while many others in the village of defeated-shades to which we belong prefer the latter, albeit calling for massive tribute from the defeating culture in order to be able to fund their desired zoo lives in comfort. Still others in the village are undecided, or proponents of other, exotic and little-known, equally or increasingly unwieldy propositions.
The first is slightly more influential in government; the second is very influential in the creators of entertainment. Thus, while society is to a degree deadlocked, I was for a time subject to a number of pieces of popular entertainment which, more often than others would like to admit, contained a hidden theme of people from an idyllic culture much unlike any which -actually- exist but much like the ones the second group espouses, who travel to a land containing a different culture because they want to learn from them, then proceed to intentionally change the culture they visit in fairly profound ways while simultaneously withholding lasting aid for fear of "contaminating their culture". The changed culture of these performances is almost always grateful for being shown the error of their ways, or at the very least, is able to pat themselves on the back and gloat at their superiority at the end. These performances became very popular and influential amongst many people I know, and were held up as an ideal of intercultural relations.
I would guess that more of those responding, in those cases where it matters, are of the latter faction than the former, judging from the things I have seen written.
Re: Defeated color shades in monster culture
Date: 2005-05-02 08:39 pm (UTC)[Bard notes that Sythyry is more obtuse than usual. Primes certainly treat nonprimes as badly as Europeans treated Native Americans, or worse: exermination or eviction are the main approaches, with the occasional reservation of some tolerated sort of nonprime here or there. Integration into prime society is impossible. Primes generally have no respect for native traditions or culture, and are not likely to be generous in distributing their own advantages to nonprimes.]
[But Sythyry isn't thinking of that. With the usual prime bias, zie is only thinking of how primes treat primes. Ignoring various minority groups, zie's right, they don't. Of course, ignoring various minority groups is precisely the evil in question.]
Re: Defeated color shades in monster culture
From:Re: Defeated color shades in monster culture
From:Re: Defeated color shades in monster culture
Date: 2005-05-02 09:06 pm (UTC)A simple spont would have solved the problem of lifting the wagon, and possibly reparing the wheel (anybody got any idea if tires are Durador or Corpador since they're petroleum derived?), but that's not an option for us. Fortunatelty one of Justicezero's type of people saw what happened (we were at a kind of "oasis" we call a truck stop that was located on their land), and he used his own lifting device to allow me to rescue mine and complete the repair of my wagon wheel. I gave him all the money I had on me in gratitude; it was only the equivalent of about one or two lozen. I know that I would have hated accepting money for simply doing a good deed; but the fact is that these are some of the poorest people on my entire world-branch, and even if the old man didn't need the money himself, I'm sure he knows someone that does.
Another of the same type of people, but a different tribe (Pueblo this time instead of Acona), struck up a friendship with us while we were staying at an inn where he worked for the night. He was a poet and a writer, and his personality burned with such intensity that he seemed to give off sparks. He gave us a blessing to protect us on the way home; we had no further troubles.
What's crazy is that most of "us" (the invaders that justicezero spoke of) have at least some of his people's blood in our veins (somethign like 1/32 or 1/64th in my case).
When I read about the Cyarr, I keep thinking of the people "we" conquered.
Loxley
Re: Defeated color shades in monster culture
From:no subject
Date: 2005-05-04 09:48 pm (UTC)There is a difference is the base strength of our peoples. Your monsters, and even yourselves, are without knowledge equal to or greater than an average human. You seem to carry an inherent ability to use limited magic without any training. We, on the other hand, have only some unimpressive physical skills and our apparently unequaled (on our planet) minds.
Like your world, a source of power for our people is stored knowledge. On my world -- and I must now confess to not being any sort of hulking bat monster! -- our greatest strength is in our stored knowledge. Verbal, literary, electronic, etched, ect., we store the discoveries, insights, and ways on mediums that far outlive our puny life span. Without the knowledge of the past passed on we would be boggling at how to make fire. In this way humanity seems to improve, when the reality is that our storage knowledge and persistent works merely improve, while our race changes relatively little.
I wonder if stored knowledge is our only "immortal." Unlike you, we do not have the ancients and their wisdom, only their words passed through the generations. I think this is also a major difference, though it would seem to not make so very much difference, as it would seem the World Tree inhabitants make the mistakes of the past just as we do. Or, perhaps, the quantity of immortals is insuffcient to make a very obvious impact. To test, we need more immortals.
And finally while your gods are very obvious, our gods, at least to me, are very secretive to the point I wonder if they exist at all. I have yet to meet a god and know it! (Except perhaps Stored Knowledge who will give much information, but not always the wisdom to use it right.) We have had so many, and DO have so many, and we fight over their existence and their real or imagined works. This is a big difference! I have never heard of the World Tree inhabitants fighting their god's battles, or relying on faith to know they exist. Does this occur on your world?
Please pass this on to Iska if it is all very boring to you!
no subject
Date: 2005-05-04 09:53 pm (UTC)Also, "we store the discoveries" = "we store our discoveries."
no subject
Date: 2005-05-11 03:09 am (UTC)Well ... faith in the gods is not optional for primes, since we have psychic limbs that more or less attach us to them. That's "faith" in the sense of "certainty that they exist and are powerful beasties who provide us with magic". We have no such certainty that they created the world as they claim to have done. We have considerable certainty that they are not all beneficient and kindly beings devoted to our wellbeing -- indeed, they all have malevolent streaks and enjoy troubling us.
We don't fight their battles. It'd be kind of hard to choose sides, y'know. Would you rather be without air, or be without mind?
(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From: